Unpacking the Consideration Clause: Your Guide to Enforceable Contracts

Change is almost inevitable in construction. From shifting client needs to unexpected snags on site, project plans rarely unfold exactly as drawn. That’s where change orders come in – a critical, yet often challenging, part of the construction landscape.

Mismanaging them can lead to budget blowouts, schedule delays, and strained relationships. But handled correctly, they ensure everyone is aligned, work proceeds fairly, and crucially, contractors get paid for the adjusted scope. This guide dives into everything construction professionals need to know about managing change orders effectively, protecting your bottom line, and keeping projects on track.

What is a Change Order?

It’s a formal, written amendment to an existing construction contract. Think of it as a mini-agreement that modifies the original deal after it’s already signed and work may have begun. Its primary purpose is to document alterations to the project, ensuring clarity and agreement between the owner, contractor, and sometimes the architect or engineer.

Legally, a change order modifies the original contract’s terms, specifically impacting one or more of these key areas:

• Scope of Work: Detailing additions, deletions, or modifications to the tasks originally agreed upon.
• Contract Price: Adjusting the total payment amount to reflect the changed scope (either increasing or decreasing it).
• Project Schedule: Modifying completion dates or milestones due to the impact of the changes.

Without this formal documentation, performing extra work or altering the plan can lead to disputes, non-payment, and significant financial risk.

Importance and Purpose of Change Orders: When Do You Need it?

Change orders aren’t arbitrary; they are triggered by specific events that necessitate a deviation from the original contract. Understanding these common triggers helps anticipate and manage them proactively. Here are some frequent reasons why a change order becomes necessary in construction:

• Unforeseen Site Conditions: Discovering unexpected obstacles like rock formations, poor soil quality, or hidden utilities requires plan adjustments.
• Design Errors or Omissions: Mistakes or missing details in the original plans or specifications often surface during construction, necessitating corrections.
• Client-Requested Changes: Owners may decide to alter finishes, add features, or change the layout mid-project (scope creep is a common challenge).
• Regulatory Changes: New building codes, safety regulations, or environmental requirements imposed after the contract signing can force modifications.
• Material or Labor Issues: Unavailability or significant price fluctuations of specified materials, or unforeseen labor shortages, might require substitutions or schedule adjustments.
• Differing Site Conditions: When actual site conditions materially differ from what was represented in the contract documents.

What are the Crucial Elements of a Change Order?

A well-drafted change order leaves no room for ambiguity. To be effective and enforceable, it needs to contain specific details clearly outlining the modification. While templates vary, a comprehensive change order typically includes:

• Clear Identification: Project name, contract number, change order number, and date.
• Parties Involved: Names and contact information for the owner, contractor, and architect/engineer (if applicable).
• Reference to Original Contract: Clearly state which contract agreement is being modified.
• Detailed Description of the Change: Precisely explain the work being added, deleted, or altered, referencing relevant drawings or specifications.
• Impact on Contract Price: State the cost adjustment (increase, decrease, or no change) associated with the change, often broken down into labor, materials, and equipment. Include justification for markup on overhead and profit.
• Impact on Contract Time: Specify any adjustments to the project schedule or completion date resulting from the change.
• Signatures: Dated signatures from authorized representatives of the owner and contractor are essential for indicating agreement and making the change order legally binding.

Different Types of Change Orders Explained

Change orders aren’t one-size-fits-all. They come in different forms depending on the nature of the change and how the cost is determined. Understanding these types helps in negotiating and managing them effectively:

• Additive Change Order: Increases the scope of work and typically increases the contract price and potentially the schedule.
• Deductive Change Order: Reduces the scope of work, usually resulting in a decrease in the contract price. Calculating the credit amount accurately is crucial.
• Zero-Cost Change Order: Modifies the work (e.g., substituting materials of equal value) without affecting the contract price or schedule. Requires documentation nonetheless.
• Lump Sum Change Order: A fixed price is agreed upon for the specific change in scope before the work commences. This offers cost certainty but requires accurate upfront estimation.
• Time and Materials (T&M) Change Order: Used when the scope or effort is difficult to define upfront. The contractor is reimbursed for actual labor costs, material costs, and equipment usage, plus an agreed-upon markup. Requires meticulous tracking and documentation. It’s distinct from a time and materials contract but applies the same pricing mechanism to a specific change.

Navigating the Flow: The Construction Change Order Process Step-by-Step

A structured process is key to managing change orders efficiently and minimizing disruption. While specifics can vary based on the contract, the typical lifecycle involves these stages:

• Initiation: The need for a change is identified (by owner, contractor, or designer). The initiating party typically issues a formal notification or request, like a Request for Information (RFI) or Construction Change Directive (CCD), outlining the potential change.
• Review and Evaluation: All relevant parties (owner, contractor, designer) review the proposed change to understand its scope, necessity, and potential impacts.
• Cost and Schedule Estimation: The contractor prepares a detailed estimate of the cost (labor, materials, equipment, overhead, profit) and time impact associated with the proposed change. This often involves input from subcontractors and suppliers.
• Negotiation: The owner and contractor discuss the proposed cost and schedule adjustments. This stage requires clear communication and justification from the contractor to reach a fair agreement.
• Formal Approval: Once terms are agreed upon, the official change order document is drafted and circulated for signatures from authorized representatives of the owner and contractor. Crucially, work on the change should not begin before this written approval is secured.
• Implementation: With the signed change order in hand, the contractor executes the modified work according to the agreed terms.
• Tracking and Documentation: Throughout the process, meticulous records are kept – communications, cost breakdowns, time sheets, material receipts, photos, and the signed change order itself. This documentation is vital for payment applications and resolving potential disputes. Centralizing contract-related documents and communications within a robust CLM system can significantly improve this tracking.

Common Challenges in Change Order Management

Despite being routine, change orders are fraught with potential challenges that can derail projects and impact profitability. Common issues include:

• Delays in Approval: Slow review and approval processes, particularly from the owner’s side, can halt progress on the changed work and have knock-on effects on the overall project schedule.
• Disputes Over Cost or Scope: Disagreements about the necessity of the change, the fairness of the price, or the extent of the work included are frequent sources of conflict.
• Inadequate Documentation: Poorly detailed change orders or insufficient backup documentation make it difficult to justify costs and track impacts, often leading to payment issues.
• Impact on Cash Flow: Contractors often finance the cost of changed work upfront but may face significant delays in getting paid for approved change orders, straining their financial resources, as highlighted by industry groups like the Associated General Contractors of America (AGC).
• Schedule Disruption: Integrating changed work smoothly into the existing project schedule without causing delays or impacting other trades requires careful planning and coordination.
• Scope Creep: Multiple, poorly controlled small changes can accumulate, significantly altering the project’s overall scope and budget without formal recognition through consolidated change orders.

Why Do Change Orders Cost So Much? Unpacking the Expenses

It often seems like change order work costs disproportionately more than similar work in the base contract. Why is that? The price tag isn’t just about the direct cost of new materials and labor. Several factors contribute to the higher expense:

• Direct Costs: Obvious costs like labor hours, material purchases, and equipment rental specifically for the changed work.
• Indirect Costs (Overhead & Profit): Contractors add markups to cover project overhead (site supervision, administration, insurance) and profit. Markups on change orders can sometimes be higher to account for the increased risk and administrative effort involved. Typical markups can range but need justification.
• Impact Costs: This is often the most significant and debated factor. Changes can disrupt workflow, potentially requiring:
• Demobilization/Remobilization: Stopping work on one task, moving crews and equipment, and then restarting.
• Schedule Acceleration: Needing overtime or extra resources to get back on schedule after delays caused by the change process.
• Reduced Productivity: Working in already completed areas or out of sequence can be less efficient.
• Material Price Escalation: Delays might mean materials cost more than originally budgeted.
• Increased Administrative Burden: Estimating, negotiating, documenting, and tracking the change requires extra administrative time.

Accurately capturing all these potential impacts is crucial for fair pricing but challenging, underscoring the need for detailed record-keeping.

Smart Strategies and Best Practices for Change Order Success

Proactive management is the best defense against change order chaos. Implementing best practices can streamline the process, protect profitability, and maintain positive working relationships. Consider these actionable strategies:

• Clear Contract Clauses: Ensure the original contract clearly defines the change order process, including notification requirements, timelines for contract review and approval, markup percentages, and dispute resolution methods.
• Meticulous Documentation: From the initial RFI to the final sign-off, document everything. Use daily logs, photos, emails, and formal correspondence to create a clear audit trail. This is your best defense in case of disputes.
• Prompt Notification: Notify the owner or architect immediately and formally as soon as a potential change event is identified, adhering strictly to the contract’s notification requirements.
• Accurate & Detailed Estimates: Invest time in preparing comprehensive cost and time estimates for proposed changes. Break down costs clearly and justify markups and potential impact costs.
• Negotiate Fairly, Stand Firm: Understand your costs and the contract terms. Negotiate assertively but fairly, providing clear justification for your pricing and schedule adjustments.
• Never Proceed Without Written Approval: This is a golden rule. Starting changed work without a signed change order exposes you to the significant risk of non-payment.
• Streamline Approvals: Work with the owner and design team to establish efficient communication channels and reasonable timelines for the review and approval process.
• Link Change Orders to Payment Applications: Ensure approved change order amounts are promptly included in subsequent payment applications, with clear references to the authorizing document.
• Leverage Technology: Utilize construction management software or even dedicated CLM Platform to manage contracts, track changes, automate workflows, store documentation centrally, and improve visibility for all stakeholders.
• Build Relationships: Foster open communication and trust with owners and designers. A collaborative approach can often smooth the change order process.

Watch Your Step: Critical Pitfalls to Avoid in Change Orders

Even with best practices, certain mistakes can undermine your efforts. Be vigilant to avoid these common pitfalls:

• Performing work without a signed change order: The most critical error, often leading to payment denial.
• Submitting incomplete or unclear documentation: Weakens your position during negotiations and payment requests.
• Underestimating the true cost or time impact: Failing to account for disruption, overhead, or schedule delays can erode profits.
• Missing contractual deadlines for notification: Can invalidate your claim for compensation or time extension according to contract terms.
• Accepting verbal agreements: Always insist on written confirmation and signatures for any contract modification.

Take Control of Change: Key Steps for Construction Pros

Change orders are an inherent part of the construction process, bringing both challenges and opportunities. By understanding their purpose, anticipating triggers, meticulously following a defined process, and accurately accounting for costs and impacts, contractors can navigate changes effectively.

Mastering change order management isn’t just about paperwork; it’s about protecting your project’s financial health, minimizing risk, ensuring fair compensation for all work performed, and maintaining strong client relationships. Implementing robust documentation practices, leveraging technology like Sirion’s AI-Native CLM platform for contract visibility and compliance, and adhering to contractual obligations are key steps toward turning potential headaches into managed adjustments for project success.

—

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)