- 15 min read
- BETHANY MULLINIX
Introduction
In the fast-paced world of business, automatic contract renewals seem like an easy, time-saving win, right? Maybe.
It’s true that auto-renewal contracts are convenient, and they can save time in review and negotiations. However, their disadvantages could not only be costing your business money but also making it non-compliant with current regulations.
Let’s delve into auto-renewal contracts and explore their business benefits and drawbacks, especially for large enterprises. We’ll also examine how a Contract Lifecycle Management (CLM) platform can help you navigate their complexities and avoid potential financial pitfalls.
What is an Automatic Contract Renewal?
An automatic contract renewal is a contract provision stipulating an agreement will be automatically extended for a specified period unless one of the parties terminates it.
Think about software subscriptions. Many renew annually, and unless you cancel before the current subscription’s expiration date, you’re automatically signed up for another year, typically with the same terms and conditions.
Are Auto-renewal Contracts Legal?
Yes, auto-renewal contracts are legal, but they’re subject to state and federal regulations. How deeply government regulators scrutinize them depends on whether they’re a business-to-business (B2B) auto-renewal agreement or a business-to-consumer (B2C) one.
Regulators typically treat businesses that enter into B2B auto-renewal contracts as equals, with both having access to legal teams who can review their contracts. State laws usually go further toward protecting consumers in B2C in auto-renewal contracts, assuming they have less access to legal information and protection.
Advantages of Auto Contract Renewal
Before we look at their potential drawbacks, let’s acknowledge the benefits of automatic contract renewals.
First, they provide a predictable revenue stream. You’ll know when and how much you’ll pay for goods and services. And this can help you simplify your budgeting and business forecasting.
Because you’ll receive the same goods and services from the same supplier, you’ll save time because you won’t need to renegotiate terms if you’re pleased with the products or services you’re receiving. Plus, with an automatic renewal clause, you won’t have to worry about service interruptions due to a change of vendors or contractual obligations.
Disadvantages of Over-Reliance on Auto-renewal
Despite their benefits, relying on auto-renewal contracts can have significant disadvantages,, ultimately impacting a business’s bottom line.
Often Mismanaged
You’ve probably heard the term “set it and forget it.” It’s meant to describe a benefit, but “forgetting it” can be a costly disadvantage with auto-renewal contracts. By forgetting to track the performance of the contract or properly managing vendors, you could be overlooking key data or insights and missing business opportunities.
Unexpected Financial Commitments
Auto-renewal contracts can make contract termination deadlines easy to miss, potentially locking your business into a contract for a product or service you no longer want or need. If you have to contract with an alternate vendor because you’re unsatisfied with the current one, you’ll risk overpaying for that resource.
Inflexible Terms and Lack of Negotiation Leverage
Most auto-renewal contracts offer little or no flexibility in their terms. Also, you’ll lose any contract negotiation leverage that comes with annually reviewing and renegotiating contracts. With auto-renewals, you lose that advantage and remain locked into your initial terms and price.
Misalignment with Business Goals
Business needs and goals are always changing – it’s how businesses stay competitive in an equally fast-changing world. If automatic renewal clauses in your vendor contracts don’t adequately account for these changes, your business can be locked into agreements that no longer align with its current objectives.
Regulatory and Compliance Risks
Business and technology can change quickly – so can legal and regulatory standards. Unless your business actively monitors auto-renewal terms against local and federal regulations, you or vendors could fall into non-compliance and face legal consequences. There are many other types of contract risk too.
Leads to Duplicate Vendors Across Functions
It’s easy for large companies, in particular, to run into the issue of duplicate vendors with auto-renewals.
Let’s again use a software platform as our example. If different teams use the same software but under separate contracts, they’re potentially losing discount and negotiation leverage with that vendor. With auto-renewal contracts (and without a central team actively reviewing them), this could become a long-term, unnecessary financial drain.
Changing Laws and Regulations to Curb Auto-renewal
Regulators are increasingly scrutinizing auto-renewal agreements to protect all parties involved in contracts.
Most of the attention from legislators has focused on B2C auto-renewal contracts. In 2021, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission issued an enforcement policy statement warning companies against deploying illegal “dark patterns that trick and trap consumers into subscription services.”
However, New York and Wisconsin have also tightened their B2B auto-renewal regulations.
How to Mitigate Auto-renewal Agreement Risks
Keeping up with automatic contract renewal terms – and the changing regulatory environment surrounding them – can be tricky. Here are a few strategies to help you and your business get the most from auto-renewal contracts.
Conduct a Regular Comprehensive Contract Review
- Regularly audit all existing contracts to ensure awareness of auto-renewal clauses.
- Work with your legal team to identify unfavorable terms.
Establish Clear Internal Communications Channels
- Ensure your legal, procurement, and finance teams are always in sync about handling auto-renewal contracts.
- Set auto-reminders for key stakeholders about approaching renewal dates.
- Assign a team member to be responsible for overseeing each contract’s lifecycle.
Incorporate Break Clauses
- Don’t wait for the renewal deadline to review a contract. Integrate a review period to review contract performance.
- Link contract renewal to performance metrics to ensure the vendor upholds their contractual obligations. Use this information to develop potential renegotiation or exit options.
Thoroughly Understand Termination Clauses
- Make sure that the terms for contract termination are clear and understood by all parties.
- Ensure there’s sufficient time to make a renewal decision.
- Be fully aware of any penalties or fees associated with termination to avoid unexpected costs.
Utilize CLM Technology to Avoid Manual Contract Renewal Processes
- Leverage CLM systems to automatically track, remind, and alert all stakeholders about upcoming renewals.
- Flag contracts with renewal clauses to ensure they’re reviewed prior to the autorenewal deadline.
- Integrate a CLM platform with other enterprise systems (like enterprise resource planning or customer relationship management systems) for seamless contract management.
- Use analytics and reporting to gain insights into renewal trends and associated costs.
Implement Internal Training Programs
- Conduct training sessions for teams involved in the contract management process to keep them updated about best practices.
- Create hypothetical scenarios to prepare teams for potential renewal situations.
- Loop in external experts for specialized training or to provide updates on legal standards or industry practices.
Navigate Automatic Contract Renewal Clauses With a CLM
Although automatic contract renewals offer convenience, they hold significant business risks – especially in a world where regulations and business goals frequently change. CLM platforms can help your business tap into the convenience of auto-renewals without succumbing to their pitfalls.
Providing your contract management team with comprehensive CLM technology can help ensure automatic contract renewals align with your best business interests, allowing for flexibility, transparency, and strategic decision-making.
Ready to explore how an AI-powered CLM platform can help your business leverage auto-renewal contracts? Request a personal demo today!
Additional Resources
Contract Renewals: Everything Your Business Needs to Know
Essentials of Contract Obligation Compliance Management
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
