What Makes a Contract Enforceable? Key Elements Explained

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Ever sealed a deal on a handshake? Hired a freelancer for a project? Even when you sell a used laptop online, you’re stepping into the world of contracts. We make agreements all the time, but a crucial question often gets overlooked until it’s too late: if things go south, will that agreement actually hold up?

This isn’t just a question for corporate lawyers in high-rise buildings. Understanding what makes a contract legally enforceable is a fundamental skill for anyone in business, from startup founders to independent contractors. It’s the difference between a reliable promise and an empty one.

Think of it as the foundation of your agreement. Without a solid, enforceable base, the entire deal can crumble under the slightest pressure. This guide will walk you through the essential components of an enforceable contract in simple terms, helping you create agreements that are built to last.

What Is an Enforceable Contract?

At its core, an enforceable contract is a promise or a set of promises that the law will uphold. If one party fails to keep their end of the bargain, the other party has legal recourse and can ask a court to step in and enforce the terms or award damages.

It’s a formal recognition that your agreement has crossed the line from a casual conversation to a binding commitment. This is a critical concept in contract law, as it provides the security and predictability that allow businesses and individuals to collaborate with confidence. An agreement without enforceability is just a suggestion.

Discover in the blog Essential Elements of a Valid Contract how to turn promises into enforceable commitments.

Your 5-Point Checklist for an Enforceable Contract

So, how do you ensure your agreement isn’t just a suggestion? It needs to contain five key ingredients. Think of it as a pre-flight checklist before your agreement can take off. If you’re missing any of these, you risk being grounded.

Before we dive deep into each point, here’s a quick overview of what you’ll need:

Offer: One party must propose a clear deal to another.
Acceptance: The other party must agree to the exact terms of the offer.
Consideration: Both sides must exchange something of value.
Capacity: Everyone involved must be legally capable of entering into a contract.
Legality: The purpose of the contract must be legal.

Before diving deeper, there’s one additional foundation to keep in mind: where and under whose laws your agreement will be judged.

Why Governing Law Matters

Even the most well-drafted agreement can unravel if there’s a dispute about which jurisdiction applies. A governing law clause specifies which state or country’s laws will interpret the contract. This reduces uncertainty and prevents one party from shopping for a friendlier legal system.

Bringing the Enforceable Contract Checklist to Life, Step-by-Step

Understanding the enforceable contract list is the first step; seeing how the pieces fit together is what truly matters. Let’s break down each element with real-world examples to show how an idea transforms into a legally sound contractual agreement.

1. The Offer: Making a Clear Proposal

An offer is a specific promise to do (or not do) something in exchange for something else. It must be clear, definite, and communicated to the other party, creating a power of acceptance.

Do: “I will design a five-page website for your bakery for $2,000.” This is specific and leaves no room for confusion.
Don’t: “I’ll help you with your website sometime.” This is vague and non-committal, making it an invitation to negotiate, not a formal offer.
Common Mistake: Vague Language. The most frequent error is making an offer that is too general. Terms like “a reasonable price” or “in a timely manner” can be subjective and difficult to enforce. Be as specific as possible about what is being offered and what is expected in return.

2. Acceptance: Saying “Yes” to the Deal

Acceptance is the clear, unambiguous agreement to the terms of the offer. It must mirror the original offer without making significant changes. If the other party proposes changes, that’s not an acceptance—it’s a counter-offer, which kills the original offer and starts the process anew.

Do: “Yes, I accept your offer to design a five-page website for $2,000.”
Don’t: “I’ll do it for $2,500.” This is a counter-offer, not an acceptance.

3. Consideration: The Exchange of Value

This is one of the most misunderstood concepts. Consideration is the “what’s in it for me?” part of the deal. Each party must give something of value and receive something of value. This is what distinguishes a contract from a gift.

The value doesn’t have to be equal, but it must be real. It can be money, goods, services, or a promise to do or not do something. For a deeper look, you can explore the principles of consideration in contract law.

Do: A freelance writer provides a blog post (service) in exchange for $300 (money). Both sides gain something.
Don’t: A person promises to give their friend a car as a gift when they turn 30. Since the friend isn’t giving anything in return, this is a one-sided promise, not an enforceable contract.
Common Mistake: Past Consideration. You cannot base a contract on something that has already been done. For example, if your neighbor mows your lawn without you asking, and you later promise to pay them $50 for it, that promise may not be enforceable because the “service” was performed before the promise was made.

4. Capacity: Ensuring Everyone Is on Equal Footing

For a contract to be valid, all parties must have the legal and mental ability to understand what they are doing. This is known as having contractual capacity.

Generally, certain groups of people are presumed to lack capacity, including:

Minors: Individuals under the age of 18 typically cannot be held to contracts, though there are exceptions for necessities like food and lodging.
Individuals with mental incapacities: Someone who cannot understand the nature and consequences of the agreement may lack capacity.
Those under the influence: A person who is severely intoxicated or impaired may be deemed incapable of consenting.

5. Legality: Keeping It Above Board

This one is simple: a court will not enforce a contract for an illegal purpose. The subject matter of the agreement must be lawful.

Do: A contract to purchase legally sourced raw materials for manufacturing.
Don’t: A contract to hire someone to hack a competitor’s database. This contract is void from the start because its purpose is illegal.

Even with all five elements present, contracts can still fail in practice. The real challenge lies in avoiding common drafting and execution pitfalls that undermine enforceability.

Find out in the blog Contract Management Challenges how to turn common obstacles into opportunities for stronger agreements.

Common Pitfalls to Watch Out For

Vague or Ambiguous Language: Terms like “reasonable price” or “timely delivery” are open to interpretation and often contested in court.
Missing Signatures: An unsigned agreement, unless supported by strong evidence of intent, risks being challenged.
Ignoring Jurisdiction: Without a governing law clause, disputes can spiral into lengthy battles over which state or country’s laws apply.
Improper Form: Certain contracts (real estate, long-term agreements) must be in writing under the Statute of Frauds. Skipping this makes them unenforceable.

Theory is useful, but contracts live and breathe in real situations. Here are some everyday examples where enforceability—or the lack of it—makes all the difference.

Enforceability in Action: Practical Scenarios

Freelance Agreement (Enforceable): A signed contract specifying scope of work, timeline, and payment terms.
Handshake Business Deal (Often Unenforceable): Without documentation, proving offer, acceptance, and consideration is difficult.
Rental Lease (Voidable): A tenant under 18 signs a lease; the contract exists but can be canceled due to lack of capacity.
Sale of Real Estate (Unenforceable if Verbal): Property transactions must be in writing to hold up in court.

Lost in Translation? Unraveling Enforceable vs. Unenforceable vs. Void Contracts

The legal world loves its precise terminology, and this is where many people get tripped up. While the terms “unenforceable,” “void,” and “voidable” might sound similar, they describe very different situations. Getting them straight is key to understanding your risks.

This is often the most confusing part for non-lawyers, so we’ve created a simple breakdown to clarify the differences.

Here’s a closer look at what each term means:

Enforceable Contract: A legally valid contract that a court can enforce. It meets all five criteria we discussed.
Unenforceable Contract: A contract that may have been valid at one point, but a legal defense now prevents it from being enforced. A common example is a contract that must be in writing (like those for the sale of land) but was only made verbally. Another is when the statute of limitations—the time limit for filing a claim—has passed.
Void Contract: A contract that was never legal from the moment it was created. It lacks one of the essential elements, most often legality. A contract to commit a crime is a classic example. It’s considered a legal nullity and cannot be enforced by either party.
Voidable Contract: A contract that is valid but could be canceled by one of the parties. The party with the option to cancel can either enforce the contract or void it. This typically happens when one party lacked capacity (e.g., they were a minor) or was a victim of fraud, duress, or undue influence.

Knowing what makes a contract enforceable is one side of the coin. The other side is understanding what happens if someone breaks it.

Find out in the blog Breach of Contract the key types of breaches and the actions you can take to protect your interests.

What Courts Can Do: Remedies for Breach

Compensatory Damages: Monetary award to put the injured party in the position they would have been if the contract was honored.
Specific Performance: A court order requiring the breaching party to carry out their promise (common in real estate).
Rescission: Canceling the contract and restoring both parties to their original positions.
Restitution: Requiring the breaching party to return benefits they unfairly received.

Your Path to Sounder Agreements

Creating an enforceable contract isn’t about memorizing legal code; it’s about being clear, fair, and deliberate. By using the five-point checklist—Offer, Acceptance, Consideration, Capacity, and Legality—you can move forward with confidence, knowing your agreements are built on a solid foundation.

However, a strong start is only half the battle. Once signed, a contract begins its own lifecycle of performance, obligations, and potential amendments. Ensuring the value promised in the agreement is actually delivered requires ongoing attention. A thorough contract review process and diligent management are what truly separates a successful deal from a piece of paper filed away and forgotten.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Are oral contracts enforceable?

Yes, in many cases, verbal or oral contracts can be legally enforceable. If you can prove the five essential elements existed (offer, acceptance, consideration, capacity, legality), a verbal agreement can be just as valid as a written one. However, the major challenge is evidence. Proving the specific terms of a verbal contract can be incredibly difficult, often boiling down to a “he said, she said” situation. Certain types of contracts, such as those for the sale of real estate or agreements that cannot be completed within one year, are legally required to be in writing under a rule known as the Statute of Frauds.

Does a contract need to be written by a lawyer to be enforceable?

No, you do not need a lawyer to draft an enforceable contract. As long as the agreement contains all the essential elements, it can be legally binding. Many businesses use templates or create their own simple contracts for routine transactions. However, for complex, high-value, or high-risk agreements, consulting with a lawyer is highly recommended to ensure your interests are protected and you haven’t overlooked any critical details or potential legal pitfalls.

What happens if a small part of my contract is illegal?

This depends on the contract’s language and the nature of the illegality. Many well-drafted contracts include a “severability clause.” This clause states that if any part of the contract is found to be illegal or unenforceable, the rest of the contract will remain in full force and effect. The court will essentially “sever” the illegal portion and enforce the remainder. Without this clause, a court might declare the entire contract void.

Is an email exchange considered an enforceable contract?

An email exchange can absolutely form an enforceable contract, provided it meets the five core requirements. The emails must show a clear offer (“Will you buy my 10 widgets for $100 each?”), an unambiguous acceptance (“Yes, I will buy your 10 widgets for $100 each”), and contain the other elements. Courts have increasingly recognized electronic communications as valid ways to form a contractual agreement. The key is whether the a reasonable person would conclude from the correspondence that an agreement was reached.

Are electronic signatures and online agreements enforceable?

Yes. Under laws such as the U.S. E-SIGN Act and the EU’s eIDAS Regulation, electronic signatures hold the same legal weight as handwritten ones. Clickwrap agreements (where you click “I agree”) and DocuSign-style e-signatures are generally enforceable, provided the user had clear notice of the terms and took an affirmative action to accept.

Can an unsigned contract still be enforceable?

Yes, in some cases. If both parties clearly intended to be bound by the terms and acted on them (for example, by delivering goods or making payment), a court may enforce the agreement even without signatures. However, an unsigned contract makes proving enforceability much harder. For important agreements, always get signatures to avoid disputes.

What’s the difference between void and voidable contracts in simple terms?

A void contract was never valid to begin with—like an agreement to do something illegal. It has no legal effect and cannot be enforced by anyone.
A voidable contract starts out valid but gives one party the choice to cancel it, usually because of fraud, misrepresentation, or lack of capacity (such as a minor signing). If the party with the right to cancel doesn’t act, the contract can still be enforced.

Additional Resources

Contracts