What Is the Penalty for Breach of Contract? A Comprehensive Guide

Subscribe to our Newsletter

The moment a contract is signed, it creates a sense of security. It’s a documented promise, a foundation for a business relationship. But what happens when that foundation cracks and one party doesn’t hold up their end of the deal? The first thought that often flashes through a business owner’s mind is, “What’s the penalty?” This question can bring a wave of anxiety, with worries ranging from financial ruin to legal trouble.

Let’s clear the air on the most common fear right away: can you go to jail for a breach of contract? In the vast majority of business dealings, the answer is a simple no. A breach of contract is typically a civil matter, not a criminal one. The consequences aren’t about punishment in the way we think of fines or prison; they’re about making the wronged party whole again. This guide will walk you through what penalties for a breach of contract actually look like, moving from foundational concepts to real-world financial remedies.

First, What Actually Counts as a Breach?

Before we can talk about penalties, it’s crucial to understand what a breach is. At its core, it’s a failure to perform any promise that forms all or part of the contract without a legal excuse. However, not all breaches are created equal. The type of breach heavily influences the type and scale of the penalty.

Broadly, they fall into two categories:

Material Breach: This is a significant failure that strikes at the very heart of the agreement. It’s so severe that it defeats the purpose of the contract for the non-breaching party. For example, if you hire a company to build a website and they never deliver it, that’s a material breach.
Minor Breach (or Immaterial Breach): This is a less serious violation where the core service or product was delivered, but some part of the contract wasn’t fulfilled. For instance, if the website was delivered two days late, it’s likely a minor breach. The main goal of the contract was met, even if not perfectly.

Understanding this distinction is the first step, as a material breach opens the door to more significant damages and remedies than a minor one.

Now that we know what counts as a breach, let’s clear up one of the most common fears around it—does a breach of contract mean criminal penalties?

Civil vs. Criminal Penalties or Consequences of Breach of Contract

Most breaches of contract are civil matters, not criminal offenses. The legal system typically treats them as disputes over money or performance, rather than crimes. That means penalties usually involve damages, not jail time.

Civil Consequences: Monetary damages (compensatory, consequential, liquidated, etc.) or equitable remedies such as specific performance.
Criminal Consequences (Rare Cases): Only arise when fraud, misrepresentation, or deliberate misconduct is involved. For example, if a party intentionally falsifies records or engages in criminal deception, criminal charges may apply.

This distinction is crucial for businesses: breach ≠ crime, unless fraud or intentional illegality is involved.

For a closer look at confidentiality breaches, see our guide What happens if you break an NDA.

Exploring the Landscape of Contract Penalties

When a contract is breached, the legal system’s goal is to put the injured party back in the position they would have been in had the contract been fulfilled. This is achieved through remedies, often called “damages,” which are almost always monetary.

Here are the most common types of damages you’ll encounter, each serving a different purpose in making the wronged party whole.

Compensatory Damages: This is the most frequent remedy. It’s money awarded to cover the direct losses the non-breaching party incurred. If a supplier fails to deliver $5,000 worth of materials you paid for, your compensatory damages would be $5,000.
Consequential Damages: These are the indirect damages that happen as a foreseeable result of the breach. Imagine the supplier’s failure to deliver materials forced you to shut down production for a day. The lost profits from that shutdown would be consequential damages.
Liquidated Damages: Sometimes, the parties agree on a specific penalty amount right in the contract itself. This pre-agreed sum is meant to be a fair estimate of potential damages if a breach occurs. These are common in construction contracts where a daily fee is set for project delays.
Nominal Damages: What if a breach occurred, but no one lost any money? In this case, a court might award nominal damages—a very small amount, like $1—to acknowledge that a wrong was committed, even if no financial harm resulted.
Equitable Remedies: In rare cases where money isn’t enough, a court might order something other than cash. This could be “specific performance,” which compels the breaching party to do what they promised, or an “injunction,” which stops them from doing something.

But before we get into the fine line between penalty clauses and liquidated damages, it’s worth asking—what actually shapes the size and scope of penalties?

Factors That Influence Penalties in Breach of Contract

Several factors determine how serious the financial and legal consequences of a breach will be:

Contract Terms: Clauses that define damages, limitations of liability, or dispute resolution methods heavily influence outcomes.
Severity of Breach: A material breach triggers more significant penalties compared to a minor one.
Jurisdiction: Contract laws differ by state or country. Some courts strictly enforce liquidated damages, while others scrutinize them closely.
Foreseeability of Damages: Courts ask whether the damages claimed were reasonably foreseeable at the time of contract formation.
Mitigation Efforts: The non-breaching party must take reasonable steps to reduce their losses; otherwise, damages awarded may be reduced.

These factors explain why two similar breaches can lead to very different outcomes.

For the bigger picture on how contracts can end, explore our guide on the Discharge of Contract.

The All-Important Difference: Penalty Clause vs. Liquidated Damages

One of the most misunderstood areas of contract law is the difference between a penalty clause and a liquidated damages clause. Here’s a side-by-side view to make it crystal clear:

Feature	Penalty Clause	Liquidated Damages Clause
Purpose	Punishes the breaching party	Compensates the non-breaching party
Amount	Excessively high, not tied to actual loss	Reasonable pre-estimate of likely loss
Enforceability	Generally unenforceable in court	Usually enforceable if reasonable
Example	$50,000/day fee for minor project delays	$500/day fee for construction delay impacting tenant move-in

Think of it this way: liquidated damages are about fairness, while penalty clauses cross the line into punishment—and that’s why courts often reject them.

Once you know which type of clause applies, the next step is understanding how damages are actually calculated in real-life disputes.

Let’s Do the Math: How Are Damages Actually Calculated?

Understanding the types of damages is one thing, but how are the numbers actually determined? For compensatory damages, the most common calculation is based on the concept of “expectation damages.” The goal is to give the non-breaching party the “benefit of the bargain.”

The basic formula looks something like this:

Expectation Damages = (Value Promised) – (Value Delivered) + (Consequential Losses) – (Costs Saved)

Let’s use a simple scenario. A marketing agency hires a freelance graphic designer to create 10 social media graphics for $1,000. The designer only delivers 5 and then disappears. The agency has to hire another designer at the last minute, who charges $800 for the remaining 5 graphics.

Value Promised: 10 graphics for $1,000.
Value Delivered: 5 graphics (worth $500).
Calculating the Loss: The agency expected to pay $1,000 for 10 graphics. They ended up paying the first designer $500 (assuming they paid half upfront) and the second designer $800, for a total of $1,300. Their loss is $300.

The compensatory damages owed by the first designer would be $300 to put the agency back in the financial position they would have been in. This calculation also reflects the non-breaching party’s “duty to mitigate”—meaning they must take reasonable steps to minimize their losses, which the agency did by hiring a replacement.

Seeing It in Action: Breach Penalties Across Industries

The principles of contract breach penalties are universal, but they manifest differently across sectors. Seeing these examples helps illustrate how these concepts work in the real world.

Construction: A general contractor hires a subcontractor to install windows in a new office building by June 1st. The contract includes a liquidated damages clause of $1,000 for each day the project is late, as a delay would postpone the tenant’s move-in date. If the subcontractor finishes on June 10th, they would owe $10,000 in liquidated damages.
Software Development: A retail company pays a software firm $100,000 to develop a new e-commerce app. The app launches full of bugs, causing frequent crashes and preventing customers from making purchases. The retail company could sue for compensatory damages to recover the $100,000 paid and consequential damages for the lost sales revenue during the period the app was unusable.
Real Estate: A buyer puts down a $15,000 earnest money deposit on a house. The purchase agreement states this deposit will serve as liquidated damages if the buyer backs out of the sale without a valid reason. If the buyer gets cold feet and cancels the deal, the seller is typically entitled to keep the $15,000 to compensate for the time the house was off the market.

Facing a Breach? Here’s What to Do Next

Whether you believe someone has breached their contract with you or you’re the one who has failed to perform, the steps you take next are critical. A contract dispute can escalate quickly, but a calm, methodical approach can often lead to a resolution without costly litigation.

If You Are the Non-Breaching Party:

Review the Contract: Carefully read the agreement to understand the exact obligations, deadlines, and any specific clauses related to breach and damages.
Document Everything: Keep a detailed record of the breach, including dates, communications, and any financial losses you’ve incurred.
Communicate in Writing: Formally notify the other party of the breach. This creates a paper trail and shows you are serious about enforcing the contract.
Consult Legal Counsel: Before taking any major action, it’s wise to speak with an attorney to understand your rights and options.

For clarity on advisory roles in contract disputes, explore our guide on Legal Counsel vs General Counsel.

If You Are the Breaching Party:

Be Honest and Proactive: Don’t ignore the problem. Communicate with the other party immediately to explain the situation.
Review the Contract: Understand your obligations and look for any relevant clauses, such as a limitation of liability clause, that might cap your potential damages.
Propose a Solution: Offer a way to remedy the breach if possible, whether it’s completing the work, offering a discount, or finding another compromise.
Seek Legal Advice: An attorney can help you understand the potential consequences and negotiate a fair settlement.

Navigating Forward with Clarity

Understanding the penalty for a breach of contract is less about fearing punishment and more about grasping the principles of fairness and compensation. The consequences are designed to restore balance, not to penalize. By knowing the difference between a material and minor breach, recognizing the various types of damages, and—most importantly—distinguishing a valid liquidated damages clause from an unenforceable penalty, you are better equipped to manage your agreements.

Ultimately, the best way to deal with contract breaches is to prevent them from happening in the first place through robust contract lifecycle management. Clear terms, proactive monitoring, and open communication are the most powerful tools for ensuring every promise made is a promise kept.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How long do you have to sue for a breach of contract?

This is determined by a law known as the "statute of limitations," which varies by state and the type of contract. For written contracts, this period is typically between three and ten years from the date the breach occurred. It's crucial to check the specific laws in your jurisdiction, as waiting too long can prevent you from filing a lawsuit.

Can a verbal agreement be breached, and are there penalties?

Yes, verbal agreements can be legally binding contracts and can be breached. However, they are much harder to enforce because there is no written document to prove the terms. If you can prove the existence and terms of the verbal agreement (through emails, text messages, witness testimony, or performance), you can sue for damages just as you would for a written contract.

What's the difference between damages and a settlement?

"Damages" are the monetary award a court orders the breaching party to pay to the non-breaching party after a successful lawsuit. A "settlement" is a voluntary agreement reached by both parties to resolve their dispute outside of court. A settlement can be negotiated at any time and often involves the breaching party paying an agreed-upon amount to avoid the time, expense, and uncertainty of a trial.

Does the penalty depend on whether the breach was intentional?

No. In contract law, penalties usually focus on the harm caused, not intent. Whether the breach was deliberate or accidental, damages are calculated the same way. Only in rare cases of fraud or bad faith might extra remedies (like punitive damages) apply.

Can a contract limit penalties for breach?

Yes. Many contracts include limitation of liability clauses that cap damages to a certain dollar amount or restrict recovery to direct damages only. While enforceable in many cases, these clauses must still comply with local laws and can be challenged if deemed unconscionable or unfair.

Additional Resources

Contract Management